publication-ethics

Publication Ethics Statement

The Journal of Higher Education Service Science and Management (JoHESSM), published by the Centre for Higher Education Research and Academic Development (CHERAD), is committed to maintaining the highest standards of ethical conduct, academic integrity, transparency, and accountability throughout the scholarly publication process.

The journal's publication ethics framework is informed by the principles and guidance of the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE) and recognised international standards of responsible research and scholarly publishing.

These principles apply to all authors, editors, reviewers, editorial board members, and individuals involved in the journal's publication activities.

1. Responsibilities of Authors

Authors are responsible for ensuring that their submissions represent original, accurate, ethically conducted, and appropriately documented scholarly work.

Authors must:

  • Submit manuscripts that have not been published previously or submitted simultaneously to another journal.

  • Present research methods, findings, and conclusions accurately and transparently.

  • Properly acknowledge all sources, contributions, and relevant prior research.

  • Avoid plagiarism, fabrication, falsification, inappropriate image manipulation, and misleading presentation of research findings.

  • Disclose relevant funding, competing interests, and the use of artificial intelligence tools where applicable.

  • Obtain necessary research ethics approvals and participant consent.

  • Cooperate with legitimate editorial requests for clarification, supporting documentation, or research data.

  • Notify the journal promptly if significant errors or ethical concerns are discovered after submission or publication.

2. Authorship and Contributorship

Authorship must reflect substantial scholarly contributions to the research and manuscript.

All listed authors must have participated meaningfully in the work, approved the submitted manuscript, and accepted responsibility for their respective contributions.

Individuals who provided technical assistance, administrative support, funding acquisition, or other contributions that do not independently justify authorship should be acknowledged appropriately.

Guest, gift, honorary, and ghost authorship are prohibited.

Changes to authorship after submission require a justified written request and agreement from all affected authors. The journal may request supporting documentation before approving such changes.

3. Plagiarism and Originality

JoHESSM does not tolerate plagiarism or deliberate misrepresentation of intellectual contributions.

Prohibited practices include:

  • Copying another person's work without appropriate attribution.

  • Presenting paraphrased material without acknowledging the original source.

  • Reusing previously published material without proper citation or necessary permission.

  • Submitting substantially overlapping manuscripts without transparent disclosure.

  • Misrepresenting the originality of research findings or intellectual contributions.

Manuscripts may be examined using similarity-detection software and editorial assessment.

Similarity percentages are not treated as automatic evidence of misconduct. Editorial evaluation considers the nature, context, attribution, and significance of any identified overlap.

Confirmed serious violations may result in manuscript rejection, correction, retraction, or other appropriate action.

4. Research Ethics Approval

Research involving human participants, identifiable personal information, clinical records, biological materials, or animals must comply with applicable legal, institutional, and disciplinary ethical requirements.

Authors must identify the responsible ethics committee or institutional review board, provide approval information where applicable, and explain any authorised exemption or waiver.

For human-participant research, the journal expects adherence to relevant ethical principles, including those reflected in the Declaration of Helsinki where applicable.

Animal research must comply with recognised welfare standards and applicable institutional and national requirements.

The journal may request evidence of ethics approval or clarification of ethical procedures before making a publication decision.

5. Informed Consent and Participant Privacy

Authors must obtain informed consent when required by applicable ethical standards and regulations.

Where research involves identifiable individuals, clinical information, photographs, interviews, or other potentially identifying material, authors must ensure that appropriate consent for publication has been obtained.

Participant confidentiality, privacy, and data protection must be maintained.

Removal of names alone may not be sufficient to protect identities where other identifying details remain.

Authors must clearly explain any consent waiver or exemption granted by an authorised ethics body.

6. Data Integrity, Transparency, and Availability

Research data must be collected, processed, analysed, and reported honestly and accurately.

Fabrication, falsification, selective manipulation, and intentional omission of findings that materially misrepresent the research are prohibited.

Authors should maintain appropriate research records and provide sufficient methodological information to enable critical evaluation of their findings.

Where legally and ethically permissible, authors are encouraged to make supporting data, analytical code, instruments, and relevant materials accessible through appropriate repositories or reasonable requests.

Restrictions involving patient confidentiality, participant privacy, intellectual property, or contractual obligations must be explained.

The journal may request supporting evidence where significant concerns about data integrity arise.

7. Conflicts of Interest and Funding Disclosure

Authors, reviewers, and editors must disclose relationships or interests that could influence, or reasonably appear to influence, their scholarly judgement.

These may include financial interests, employment relationships, consultancy arrangements, institutional affiliations, personal relationships, or professional collaborations.

Authors must disclose research funding and describe the funder's role in study design, data collection, analysis, interpretation, manuscript preparation, or publication decisions where relevant.

The absence of competing interests should also be explicitly declared.

Editorial decisions must remain independent of financial contributions, article processing charges, sponsorship, and institutional interests.

8. Responsibilities of Editors

Editors are responsible for maintaining the fairness, integrity, confidentiality, and scientific quality of the editorial process.

Editorial decisions must be based on scholarly merit, methodological rigour, ethical compliance, and relevance to the journal's aims and scope.

Editors must:

  • Apply editorial policies consistently and without discrimination.

  • Maintain confidentiality throughout manuscript assessment.

  • Select qualified and appropriately independent reviewers.

  • Identify and manage relevant conflicts of interest.

  • Investigate credible allegations of research or publication misconduct.

  • Protect editorial independence from commercial or institutional influence.

  • Ensure that concerns involving published articles receive appropriate consideration.

Editors must not exploit unpublished manuscript content for personal research or professional advantage.

9. Responsibilities of Reviewers

Reviewers must provide objective, constructive, evidence-based, and confidential assessments.

They are expected to evaluate manuscripts within their areas of expertise, disclose relevant conflicts of interest, and notify editors when they cannot complete an appropriate review.

Reviewers must not use unpublished findings, data, or ideas for personal benefit.

Suspected ethical violations should be reported confidentially to the handling editor.

Personal criticism, discriminatory remarks, and attempts to manipulate citations or editorial decisions are unacceptable.

10. Research and Publication Misconduct

JoHESSM considers allegations of misconduct seriously, including:

  • Data fabrication or falsification.

  • Plagiarism and substantial undisclosed text or data overlap.

  • Duplicate or redundant publication.

  • Inappropriate authorship practices.

  • Undisclosed conflicts of interest.

  • Manipulation of peer review.

  • Citation manipulation.

  • Unethical research involving humans or animals.

  • Misrepresentation or inappropriate manipulation of images and research findings.

Concerns are assessed fairly and confidentially, with consideration of relevant evidence and an opportunity for affected parties to respond.

Where appropriate, the journal may seek clarification from authors, reviewers, institutions, or other relevant parties.

Editorial action will be proportionate to the nature and seriousness of the established concern.

11. Corrections, Expressions of Concern, and Retractions

JoHESSM recognises its responsibility to maintain the accuracy and reliability of the scholarly record.

Where significant errors or ethical concerns are identified after publication, the journal may issue:

  • Corrections to address errors that do not invalidate the principal findings.

  • Expressions of Concern where substantial unresolved questions affect confidence in a publication.

  • Retractions where findings are unreliable or serious ethical or publication violations are established.

Notices should clearly identify the affected article, explain the reason for the editorial action, and remain permanently accessible.

Retractions are intended to correct the scholarly record rather than serve as punishment.

12. Editorial Independence and Publisher Responsibilities

CHERAD supports the journal's scholarly mission and recognises the independence of its editorial decision-making.

The Editor-in-Chief and authorised editors are responsible for decisions concerning manuscript acceptance, revision, and rejection.

Publication decisions must not be influenced by commercial considerations, institutional pressure, sponsorship, or the payment of article processing charges.

The publisher is responsible for supporting appropriate publication infrastructure, maintaining journal records, and facilitating the implementation of established editorial and ethical policies.

13. Complaints, Appeals, and Ethical Investigations

Authors, reviewers, readers, and other concerned parties may raise legitimate complaints regarding editorial conduct, publication ethics, research integrity, or the handling of manuscripts.

Complaints should provide sufficient information to identify the relevant manuscript or publication and explain the concern.

The journal will assess complaints objectively, maintain appropriate confidentiality, and seek responses from affected parties where necessary.

Where the Editor-in-Chief has a relevant conflict of interest, the matter should be referred to an independent editor or appropriately authorised representative.

Appeals against editorial decisions must identify a substantial procedural concern, factual error, or potential conflict of interest.

The journal may consult COPE guidance and seek institutional cooperation when investigating complex cases.

14. Commitment to Ethical Publishing

JoHESSM is committed to promoting responsible research, protecting the integrity of the scholarly record, and ensuring that publication decisions reflect transparent and internationally recognised ethical principles.

The journal periodically reviews its publication ethics policies to reflect developments in scholarly publishing, research governance, and disciplinary best practices.